The correct answer is: Use the Amazon S3 Storage Lens dashboard to review advanced activity metrics and identify low-access buckets.

S3 Storage Lens is a purpose-built analytics tool designed to provide organization-wide visibility into S3 usage and activity trends. It includes metrics like bytes retrieved, request counts, and access patterns over time. Storage Lens offers both free and advanced tiers, with minimal configuration required, and it operates across accounts and Regions. For identifying infrequently accessed buckets, Storage Lens is the most efficient and lowest-overhead solution.

The option Enable AWS CloudTrail for S3 object events and analyze access frequency through integrated CloudWatch Logs introduces significant operational complexity. While it can track data access, it produces high volumes of logs that must be manually filtered and analyzed. It also adds costs for storage and analysis, especially in environments with many buckets or frequent object events.

The option Activate the S3 BucketSizeBytes CloudWatch metric and query the data using Amazon Athena to detect idle buckets is overly complex for this use case. BucketSizeBytes tracks storage usage but does not offer direct insight into access patterns. Combining it with Athena requires exporting logs to S3, maintaining a schema, and writing queriesan involved process with higher maintenance demands.

The option Use the Amazon S3 section of the AWS Management Console to manually review access metrics for each bucket is not scalable. It may suffice for a small number of buckets, but it lacks centralized reporting, cannot handle cross-account insights, and requires manual inspection, making it unsuitable for large-scale environments or automation.

This question is valuable because it evaluates your ability to balance functionality and operational efficiency when monitoring and optimizing AWS resources. A useful trick is to prioritize purpose-built analytics tools like S3 Storage Lens over generic or manual solutions when available.

The difficulty lies in identifying which tools are optimized for monitoring at scale with minimal setup. While CloudTrail, CloudWatch, and Athena can technically solve this problem, only Storage Lens provides an integrated, low-effort dashboard specifically designed for storage access insights.

Full AWS Practitioner Certification Question